Trump, Xi reiterate ‘strategic stability’ pledge; whatever it means

President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping have reaffirmed commitment to building the “constructive relationship of strategic stability” pledged in May, but the two countries have yet to establish its meaning for growing nuclear and strategic competition.

The leaders agreed during Xi’s Sept. 23-25 visit to Washington to build a strategic-stability relationship based on “respect, fairness and reciprocity,” according to the Chinese government website. The White House likewise said the two sides agreed to build such a relationship.

The agreement builds on a commitment Trump and Xi reached during their May meeting in Beijing. In an analysis by the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists published Sept. 23, Tong Zhao of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace argued that the phrase remains undefined and could carry significantly different meanings in Washington and Beijing.

Zhao wrote that Beijing has treated strategic stability as potentially encompassing U.S. restraint on issues China considers “core interests,” including Taiwan, while Washington has devoted comparatively little attention to defining the concept.

For the nuclear relationship, Zhao argued strategic stability traditionally has centered on ensuring that both sides retain confidence in their ability to retaliate after a nuclear attack. That concept could become increasingly important as the United States and China expand their nuclear arsenals while competing across conventional military capabilities, artificial intelligence and counterspace systems.

Among the measures Zhao proposed are rules prohibiting the deployment or use of nuclear weapons in space and reciprocal rules governing strategic capabilities such as missile defenses.

“The way out is to start with reciprocal standards,” Zhao said. “The two leaders can launch a dedicated expert dialogue focused on what characteristics—capability, scale, location, or deployment pattern—make a system destabilizing. Washington and Beijing can agree on this long before they possess equal arsenals, disclose full inventories, or negotiate hard numerical limits.”

Missile defense has been a longstanding point of contention, Zhao continued. Beijing argues that U.S. missile defenses could undermine China’s retaliatory capability, while Washington has raised concerns about China’s own increasingly sophisticated missile-defense systems.

The Trump-Xi meeting also produced an agreement to establish a U.S.-China “Super Intelligence” dialogue and a communication channel for incidents involving the technology, according to the White House. The next dialogue is expected by November.

More on This Topic