State Dept. Official Touts Advantages of Civil Nuclear Cooperation

Alissa Tabirian
NS&D Monitor
11/13/2015

The strength of the United States’ global partnerships on civil nuclear cooperation lie in the quality and reliability of American nuclear components and the reputational advantages they offer to foreign nations, according to a Department of State official. Thomas Countryman, assistant secretary of the Bureau of International Security and Nonproliferation, said last Friday at the White House Summit on Nuclear Energy that “the world knows that American nuclear components are built by the world’s best workers, designed by the world’s best engineers.” He added that countries purchasing American technology “know that they will also be importing the highest standards of nuclear security to prevent diversion of nuclear material to any kind of terrorist group.”

Under these peaceful nuclear cooperation deals, known as 123 agreements, the U.S. transfers nuclear material and equipment to foreign nations committed to complying with nonproliferation standards. South Korea, Norway, Kazakhstan and Brazil are among the countries that have signed 123 agreements with the U.S.

Countryman said that civil nuclear cooperation agreements offer reputational advantages, as other countries recognize American leadership “in upholding the highest standards of the nuclear nonproliferation regime” by “insisting upon open, competitive, transparency processes.” These processes build confidence “between those who build and those who are ordering those components” and are “crucial to garnering public support for nuclear construction in any country,” he said. Disadvantages, he said, include financing problems and the United States’ inability “to determine our own final plans for disposition of spent [nuclear] fuel.” Countryman pledged that the Department of State will work to maximize advantages to the U.S. nuclear industry without increasing the risk of nuclear weapons proliferation.

In This Issue

More on This Topic


Hruby says U.S. must restore its “nuclear IQ” given China-Russia challenge

BURBANK, Calif. — Former National Nuclear Security Administration Administrator Jill Hruby said the U.S. government needs to rebuild its understanding of nuclear weapons’ effects as it weighs deterrence in a changing strategic environment involving Russia, China and other nuclear-armed states.

At the third annual Outrider Nuclear Media Summit, held Oct. 22-23 at Warner Bros. Studios, Hruby called for restoring the nation’s “nuclear IQ,” saying “just building a lot of weapons over the long run does not seem like a winning strategy.” 

During Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, she said, officials in senior government roles had little grasp of how a weapon’s size, detonation location and burst height would affect damage. Those differences matter when considering a proportionate response, Hruby said. She recalled using unclassified tools to explain potential effects.

Hruby said the U.S. cannot deter two nuclear-armed peer adversaries through weapons numbers alone. “If everybody needs the same number of nuclear weapons and there’s two against one, it just doesn’t work,” she said. “There’s no math that makes that work.”

A broader deterrence strategy should include cyber and conventional capabilities, economic ties and direct communication. “We desperately need to talk to each other. We need hotlines,” she said.

Hruby also addressed the need to refurbish an aging U.S. stockpile and rebuild capabilities that had diminished after the Cold War. Responding to criticism from Greg Mello, executive director of the Los Alamos Study Group, that modernization risks a new arms race, Hruby said officials had not weakened safety, security or environmental standards to speed the work.

On AI regulation, Hruby, who serves on Anthropic’s National Security and Public Sector Advisory Council, questioned whether technical guardrails can adequately manage systems whose behavior is not fully understood. She cautioned that transparency from AI companies is no substitute for meaningful oversight. “We have to be very, very serious about that,” she said.

In This Issue







More on This Topic