Top DOE Advisor ‘Dubious’ About Incentivizing Safety Culture in Contracts

Todd Jacobson
NS&D Monitor
10/24/2014

AMELIA ISLAND, Fla.—As the Department of Energy wrestles with revamping its contracting approaches, increasing an emphasis on nuclear safety while cutting back on fee, it doesn’t appear likely to continue the approach pursued in Bechtel’s contract for the Hanford Waste Treatment Plant. The WTP contract sought to incentivize safety culture on the project by tying it to fee-earning ability, but Bruce Held, a senior advisor to Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz, said here this week at the Weapons Complex Monitor Decisionmakers’ Forum that he was “dubious” about incentivizing nuclear safety. “Relegating nuclear safety to the status of one of several performance metrics risks incentivizing in a costly and counterproductive fashion exactly the kind of tradeoffs between nuclear safety and nuclear mission that [Navy] Adm. [Hyman] Rickover recognized long ago was so unwise,” Held said. “I believe our governing contracts must recognize nuclear safety as a ‘sine qua non,’ a core value without which DOE’s nuclear mission cannot succeed.”

While he was serving as the acting NNSA administrator earlier this year, Held outlined Moniz’s interest in moving away from larger fees for the contractors that run DOE’s laboratories and sites and toward more of a “public interest” model, and that strategy is already taking root with a decision to lower the fee of Battelle Energy Alliance at Idaho National Laboratory when that contract was extended. The Department has also opened talks with other M&O contractors, including the managers of Los Alamos and Lawrence Livermore national laboratories, Bechtel and the University of California, about lowering the fees at those sites.

‘This is Kind of Like Moving the Titanic’

The strategy, Held said, is designed to more closely align the Department—and the NNSA—with its contractors, but he said no decisions had been made about how the new model would look. He noted that Moniz had asked the Secretary of Energy Advisory Board to examine the issue, and he said he hoped the Congressionally mandated NNSA governance advisory panel would also weigh in. Moniz’s recently created internal DOE Nuclear Policy Council will also address the issue, Held said. “What is clear is the fee balancing with risk ownership,” he said. “There is clearly a tradeoff between fee and risk aversion. So we’re not there yet but we’re moving in the right direction. I’m pretty happy we’re moving in the right direction.” He added: “This is kind of moving the Titanic.”

He said the aim was to construct the contracts so that cultural behaviors that are priorities for the Department are encouraged. “Personally I am dubious that relegating nuclear safety to the status of one amongst several performance metrics all subject to sliding scales of graduated financial incentives is strategically the best way to do it,” he said. “I think we need a better structure particularly between the government and the private sector that properly rewards the private sector but recognizes since DOE owns these facilities eventually we own the risk.”

Held: Nuclear Safety a Ticket to Entry

A focus on nuclear safety, however, must remain as an integral part of any contract, Held said. “My instinct is that nuclear safety becomes a ticket-to-entry-type of thing,” he said. “We really have to have absolute confidence in that and that underlies everything. We need to enable the people out in the line who are going to see issues. We need to empower those people to speak. We need to create the expectation when those people start speaking people take that concern—mid-level management, the contractors, the oversight groups, that rings a bell and we seriously address those.”

He said the recent shutdown at the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant and the pause of plutonium operations at Los Alamos National Laboratory were two examples where safety issues had a major impact on the mission of the sites. “Excellence in nuclear safety enables and drives excellence in other nuclear mission areas,” Held said. “And the absence of nuclear safety spells the end of the nuclear mission.”

Held Pushes for More S&T Research on Nuclear Safety

Held also suggested that DOE should invest more of its research money and “science and technology brainpower” on nuclear safety issues. Specifically, he said developing modern tools and simulation capabilities for analyzing seismic safety in nuclear facilities has lagged behind other advancements. “The tools available to us today are decades old and leave us with unnecessarily large margins of uncertainty,” he said. “The return on such an R&D investment on seismic safety as it applies to DOE’s defense nuclear facilities alone would be more than sufficient to justify every single dollar of that investment. … An even bigger payoff would come when the benefits of that R&D are applied to the broader civil sector, including physical infrastructure, commercial buildings, and civilian nuclear energy.”

In This Issue







More on This Topic


A nuclear power plant facility featuring two large cooling towers alongside a domed reactor containment building.

NRC issues final EIS for GLE’s planned Paducah enrichment facility

The Nuclear Regulatory Commission issued the final environmental impact statement for Global Laser Enrichment’s (GLE) proposed laser enrichment facility located near the Department of Energy’s Paducah Site in Kentucky. According to GLE’s Oct. 23 press release, NRC staff recommended issuing a license to construct and operate the facility. This issuance comes months after NRC published […]






Dems blue wave felt across DOE installations, but many GOP lawmakers return

Viewers did not need to stay up late Tuesday night to hear most major national news outlets had declared that the Democratic Party had won control of both the U.S. House of Representatives as well as the Senate as that was determined by 11:30 p.m. Eastern Time. 

CBS News reported early Wednesday morning that Democrats were seemingly assured of at least 54 seats in the Senate and around 250 in the House – with some races still undecided.  The results, while still unofficial, are considered a major blow to the agenda of President Donald Trump.

One of the biggest flips in favor of the Democrats came in Texas, home to commercial nuclear power plants and the National Nuclear Security Administration’s (NNSA) Pantex Plant. State lawmaker James Talarico (D) defeated the state’s GOP Attorney General Ken Paxton.

As for the Pantex Plant in Texas, Rep. Ronny Jackson (R-Texas), a member of the House Armed Services Committee, won re-election by defeating former Amarillo city councilman Mark Nair (D). 

Here is a quick look at some of the other races that could affect the Department of Energy’s nuclear sites or commercial nuclear plants and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

Savannah River Site: In South Carolina’s Senate race Democrat Dr. Annie Andrews defeated short-term incumbent Darline Graham, the Republican who this summer was appointed to fill the unexpired term of her late brother, Sen. Lindsey Graham.

In the House of Representatives, longtime Rep. Joe Wilson (R) was narrowly leading challenger Zyon Khalifa (D) as of Thursday morning.

Hanford Site in Washington state: Republican Amanda McKinney had a significant lead over Democrat John Duresky in an election to succeed longtime incumbent Dan Newhouse (R) a member of the House Appropriations Committee.

Energy Technology Engineering Center in California: Rep. Brad Sherman (D) won re-election, defeating Republican Larry Thompson. 

Idaho National Laboratory:  Incumbent Rep. Mike Simpson (R) won another term by defeating Democrat Ellie Gilbreath and a third-party candidate in the House race. In the Senate, incumbent Jim Risch (R), a member of the Senate Energy & Natural Resources Committee, easily won re-election over Independent Todd Achilles and other challengers.

Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in California:  Aisha Wahab (D) led fellow Democrat Melissa Hernandez with more than 50% of the votes counted. 

Los Alamos National Laboratory in New Mexico: Rep. Teresa Leger Fernández (D) defeated Martin Zamora (R) a former member of the New Mexico legislature. 

Nevada National Security Site: Incumbent Democrat Rep. Steven Horsford won re-election over Republican Copy Whipple 

Oak Ridge Site: In Tennessee, Chuck Fleischman (R), who would still be the ranking Republican on the House Appropriations Energy & Water subcommittee, easily defeating  Anna Golladay (D).

Paducah Site in Kentucky: Incumbent Rep. James Comer (R) won re-election over Democrat Drew Williams, 

Portsmouth Site in Ohio: Former Sen. Sherrod Brown (D), ousted two years ago, staged a comeback, defeating appointed incumbent Republican Sen. Jon Husted (R).In the House, Rep. David Taylor (R), incumbent defeated Democrat Jen Mazzuckelli.

While not directly in the DOE nuclear complex, incumbent Marcy Kaptur, the ranking Democrat on the House Appropriations Energy & Water subcommittee, was the projected winner by Associated Press over Republican Derek Merrin.  

Sandia National Laboratories in New Mexico: Rep. Melanie Stansbury (D) defeated Republican Ndidiamaka (Didi) Okpareke. In the U.S. Senate, incumbent Democrat Ben Ray Luján won a second term, defeating Larry Marker.

Waste Isolation Pilot Plant in New Mexico: Rep. Gabe Vasquez, an incumbent Democrat, defeated Republican Greg Cunningham.

West Valley Demonstration Project in New York: Incumbent Republican Nick Langworthy defeated Aaron Gies (D).

More on This Topic